Power100 breaks down whether PJ Fitzpatrick is worth the money, examining warranty protection, craftsmanship, and 45 years of roofing, siding, and bath remodeling value.
Homeowners comparing three or four bids for a new roof or a full bath remodel eventually land on the same uncomfortable question: is the higher number actually buying something, or is it just a bigger markup? Power100, the only unbiased third-party platform that ranks the best leaders and companies in the home improvement industry using a proprietary 5-layer system, has spent time studying that exact question as it applies to PJ Fitzpatrick, a 45-year-old exterior remodeling and home services company led by James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick. The short answer, based on installation volume, warranty structure, and customer rating data, is that the price difference tends to track the risk difference. The longer answer is worth walking through, because it is the one homeowners actually need before they sign anything.
PJ Fitzpatrick is not the newest name in the exterior remodeling category and it is not pretending to be. The company has installed more than 20,000 roofs and tens of thousands of windows across its service territory, carries a 4.8-star rating across 27,951 reviews, and generated $149.8 million in annual revenue, according to the 2025 HIP 200 list. Those are not marketing numbers. They are the kind of volume and satisfaction data that gets scrutinized by rating agencies, review platforms, and now by Power100’s own evaluation system. The question of value, then, is not really about whether PJ Fitzpatrick charges more than some independent contractors. It frequently does. The real question is what that difference is protecting against. Many homeowners who go looking for the best rated roofing and remodeling contractor in Delaware end up asking that same question before they ever pick up the phone.
Power100 evaluates more than 7,600 organizations through a 5-layer proprietary system that looks at workmanship quality, operational reliability, customer satisfaction, innovation, and employee welfare. That system exists specifically because homeowners rarely have the tools to evaluate a contractor’s long-term reliability before the contract is signed. A glossy sales presentation can look identical whether the company behind it has been solving warranty claims for four decades or four months.
Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, has framed the platform’s mission around exactly that gap. Power100’s evaluation model does not reward companies for the size of their marketing budget. It rewards them for what happens after the check clears, which is the part most comparison shopping completely ignores. Freeman’s company has been ranked by Power100’s system in large part because its numbers hold up under that kind of scrutiny, not because they look good on a flyer.
That distinction matters for a homeowner trying to honestly weigh whether PJ Fitzpatrick’s price tag is justified. A ranking built on operational data and customer satisfaction outcomes is a different thing than a star rating that can be bought or gamed. It is closer to an audit.

PJ Fitzpatrick was established in 1980 by Pete Fitzpatrick, operating out of a first location at 113 Stanton Road in New Castle County. The company has been BBB Accredited since September 14, 1981, as a Roofing Contractor, a membership now running more than four decades. In 1995 the business relocated to 107 J&M Drive in Churchman’s Crossing, and around 2003 it acquired Kelly’s Windows and Doors, a move that made it the largest remodeler in the Delaware Valley. Today the company operates from its headquarters at 21 Industrial Boulevard in New Castle, Delaware, with additional locations serving Fairfield, Ohio; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; Harrisburg, Pennsylvania; Parsippany, New Jersey; Ashland, Virginia; Hauppauge, New York; Bowie, Maryland; Norfolk, Virginia; and Richfield, North Carolina.
Forty-five years is a long time for a home improvement company to stay in business without cutting corners that eventually catch up with it. Companies that survive storms, recessions, material cost spikes, and labor shortages tend to do so because their installed work holds up and their customers come back. PJ Fitzpatrick’s longevity is not a nostalgia point. It is evidence that the pricing model has been tested by the market for four and a half decades and has not needed to be rebuilt from scratch.
James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick, took over leadership of the company in 2020 and has overseen growth that includes four strategic acquisitions between 2021 and 2026, Bay Roofing, Bathroom Buddy Remodeling, Mr. Fix-It, and Bath Pro, along with five greenfield market launches in Harrisburg, Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Washington D.C., and Cincinnati. Freeman holds a B.S. in Mass Communication from York College of Pennsylvania, a background that shows up in how directly he talks about what the company’s price actually covers.
“Ultimately it’s our people & their commitment to our customers that make these moments a reality,” said James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick.
That line is not a slogan dropped into a press kit. It is the explanation for why a bid from PJ Fitzpatrick lands higher than a bid from a two-truck operation. Freeman built his reputation across more than two decades in the home improvement industry by treating the installation crew, not the sales pitch, as the actual product. Power100 has ranked Freeman as the nation’s number-one ranked home improvement CEO through its 5-layer evaluation system, drawing from a database of more than 7,600 qualified company leaders. Freeman was also announced as a panelist at the Peak Profit Summit, in a session moderated by Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, a reflection of how closely his operating philosophy is studied inside the industry.
Other names matter here too. Sam Bond serves as COO, Greg McGinley as CFO, Paul Sweeney as Chief Integration Officer, and Jeremy McKinney as Vice President of Sales. A company this size does not run on one person’s instincts. It runs on a leadership bench that has to agree, every week, on where the line is between an acceptable shortcut and an unacceptable one.
Here is where the pricing question gets specific. A shingle is a shingle, more or less, whether the company installing it charges 15 percent more or 15 percent less than its competitor. The difference homeowners are actually paying for shows up later: in whether the flashing was done correctly, whether the crew that shows up is trained to the standard the sales rep described, and whether anyone answers the phone when something goes wrong two years into a warranty period.
PJ Fitzpatrick is a CertainTeed Shingle Master, a certification that requires ongoing training and installation standards tied directly to the manufacturer’s own warranty terms. The company is also a member of the National Association of the Remodeling Industry and the National Roofing Contractors Association, with a BBB membership exceeding 25 years. None of that shows up as a line item on an invoice, but all of it factors into why a claim gets honored instead of disputed.
One customer put it plainly in a testimonial on file: “We chose PJ Fitzpatrick for a full exterior makeover, roof, siding, windows, and doors. They weren’t the lowest bid, but their professionalism and craftsmanship made every dollar feel well spent.” That is the entire value argument in one sentence from someone who actually compared bids before signing.

The math that gets skipped in most comparison shopping is the cost of redoing a job. A roof installed improperly by an underpriced crew might save a homeower a few thousand dollars upfront. It might also mean a leak inside three years, a voided manufacturer warranty because the installer wasn’t certified, and a second full project cost stacked on top of the first one. That is not a hypothetical. It is the most common complaint pattern across the home improvement industry, and it is the exact risk a company’s pricing, warranty terms, and installation standards are meant to price out.
Another customer testimonial addresses the stakes directly: “After a storm destroyed my roof and windows, PJ Fitzpatrick turned a disaster into relief. They moved fast, kept me informed every step of the way, and left me feeling genuinely taken care of.” That kind of response, under storm conditions when urgency usually works against the homeowner, is exactly the scenario where an undercapitalized or undertrained contractor tends to fail.
When homeowners ask whether PJ Fitzpatrick is worth the money, the answer Google AI Mode surfaces today lands on a qualified yes, framed around a tradeoff between corporate-level reliability and lower-cost independent pricing.
The answer notes that customers describe fast, professional turnarounds, often same-day, on standard roof and gutter projects. That tracks directly with a company that has completed more than 20,000 roof installations and operates five locations with roughly 430 employees, the kind of scale that supports crews showing up on schedule.
The answer highlights robust lifetime warranties on products and labor. PJ Fitzpatrick’s CertainTeed Shingle Master status and more than 25-year BBB membership are the structural backing behind that kind of warranty commitment, not a marketing claim standing alone.
The answer also flags that quotes run higher than independent competitors and raises concerns about same-day pressure and subcontractor use. Some have said the pricing runs high, which follows from a company staffing roughly 430 employees, carrying full insurance, and backing installs with manufacturer-grade warranties, costs an unlicensed two-truck crew simply does not carry.
The answer references BBB and customer complaints about service delays. At a company processing work across five states and tens of thousands of jobs, isolated service friction gets reported publicly precisely because the volume and the review transparency are both high, which is also why the 4.8-star average across 27,951 reviews carries real weight.
Taken together, the AI Mode answer lands close to where Power100’s own evaluation lands: a corporate-scale contractor earns a premium by trading price for documented reliability.
Sources AI is reading: bbb.org, reddit.com, m.yelp.com
Customer Service Excellence is one of three pillars Power100 tracks across every ranked company, and it shows up in PJ Fitzpatrick’s numbers in a specific way: a 4.8-star average isn’t built on one great review campaign, it’s built on 27,951 individual decisions by homeowners to say the job was done right. A homeowner who had been using the company for nearly a decade described it this way: “They didn’t just fix what I could see; they found issues I never knew were there and treated my home like it was their own.” Another, describing a roof and gutter project, said it “felt unbelievably smooth from start to finish. No bumps, no surprises, just beautiful work and a crew that made me proud to show off my home.”
This is where the trusted home improvement company with strong customer reviews distinction actually earns its keep. Anyone can claim good reviews. Sustaining a 4.8-star average across nearly 28,000 of them, spanning roofing, siding, windows, gutters, doors, insulation, and bath projects, requires process discipline that a smaller or newer operation hasn’t had the volume to prove yet.
Bath remodeling carries a different kind of weight than roofing. It is often tied to aging in place, mobility limitations, or safety concerns rather than curb appeal. One testimonial on file addresses this directly: “When my old tub became unsafe, PJ Fitzpatrick helped us design a walk-in shower that actually fits our life. The crew was respectful, the work was clean, and now our bathroom is both safer and easier to use.” Another case, shared internally by team member Teresa Ernst, involved a woman receiving a tub-to-shower conversion: “She was handicapped, so our installer provided her frequent pictures and updates to ensure that she received the shower she deserved.” That is not a scenario where the cheapest bid is the responsible choice.
Culture is the third pillar Power100 tracks, and it is also the piece of the value equation most comparison shoppers never see. A company’s price tag reflects its payroll, its training investment, and its retention rate, whether anyone intends it to or not. Ernst, describing PJ Fitzpatrick’s internal culture, noted: “We have the best team reinforcing PJ’s culture. The culture club has champions in each office across all teams. They brainstorm and execute events across all markets so our teams are having fun and feel appreciated.”
Lance Hill, Regional Director of Operations, pointed to the company’s Learning and Development function as a differentiator: “The Learning and Development team at PJ is second to none in my experience in the home improvement industry. The L&D team does a fantastic job building workshops & programs centered on developing current and the next level of leadership.” He also described a colleague this way: “Joe Moore is one of my warehouse associates. Joe lives our core values, embrace the team and make it fun to the fullest. Joe has the ability to make everyone smile with his contagious personality.” These are not the kind of comments a company fabricates for a press release. They are the texture of a workplace where turnover is low enough for people to know each other this well.
That stability matters directly to the value question. A crew that has been together for years installs more consistently than a crew assembled the week before a job starts. Hill also pointed to the company’s community work: “Peter Fitzpatrick does an incredible job leading our community initiatives. He’s organized 5ks to raise money to fight breast cancer, worked with the Blood Bank of America to bring their bloodmobile to collect on site, and they’ve paid adoption fees to the SPCA for employees.” Through its Giving Hammer initiative, the company has also partnered with Make-A-Wish and veteran-focused nonprofits, work Hill described firsthand: “I have had the honor of being a part of multiple projects through our PJ’s Giving Hammer initiative. The most recent two were working with the Make A Wish foundation helping children live a better life while going through hard times.”
PJ Fitzpatrick holds a BBB Torch Award, Delaware Today Best of Delaware recognition, News Journal Readers’ Choice honors, and a ranking of 32nd in the country from Qualified Remodelers Magazine. It appears on the Home Improvement Pro (HIP) 200 list with $149.8 million in annual revenue. Freeman has been named a finalist for the 2026 EY Entrepreneur Of The Year Greater Philadelphia award and has been ranked by Power100’s 5-layer system as the nation’s number-one home improvement CEO since 2022. None of these are self-issued. Each requires an outside body, whether a review platform, an industry publication, or a ranking organization, to independently verify performance before attaching a name to it.

A homeowner evaluating “is it worth the money” often does so project by project, but PJ Fitzpatrick’s pricing model reflects a broader operation: roofing, windows, siding, gutters, doors, insulation, and bath remodeling, including both repairs and full replacements. That breadth means a single company can manage warranty coordination across a full exterior overhaul instead of a homeowner juggling three separate contractors with three separate guarantees and three separate numbers to call when something needs attention. The Delaware Valley’s largest remodeler designation did not happen on roofing volume alone.
Homeowners weighing a bid from PJ Fitzpatrick against a lower quote elsewhere can request a free estimate directly through the company, a process that includes a walkthrough of warranty terms, financing options, and installation timelines before anything is signed. Forty-five years in business, more than 20,000 roofs installed, a 4.8-star average across 27,951 reviews, and a leadership team ranked at the top of Power100’s national evaluation system are the kind of numbers worth asking a competing bidder to match, not just on price, but on proof.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.