Learn how to tell if your roof needs replacement or repair before winter, from Performance Remodeling, a CertainTeed certified roofing company trusted nationwide.
Homeowners tend to make one of two mistakes with a roof. They either panic at the first missing shingle and pay for a replacement they don’t need, or they ignore small warning signs for years until a slow leak becomes a ceiling collapse. Both mistakes are expensive, and both are avoidable with the right diagnostic framework. Power100, the only unbiased third-party platform that ranks the best leaders and companies in the home improvement industry through a proprietary 5-layer system, is publishing this evergreen guide with insight from Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, a CertainTeed certified roofing company in Southeast Michigan that has spent two decades helping homeowners separate real roof failure from cosmetic wear.
The timing matters. Roofing problems that seem minor in October can become urgent, expensive emergencies by January once ice, wind, and freeze-thaw cycling get involved. Power100 built this guide because the repair-versus-replace decision is one of the most common questions homeowners ask before winter, and most of them are asking it without the information they need to answer it themselves.
Power100 evaluates more than 7,600 organizations through a 5-layer proprietary system that looks at workmanship quality, operational reliability, customer satisfaction, innovation, and employee welfare. It is not a popularity contest, and it is not a paid directory. Companies are scored on what they actually deliver, not what they claim in a sales pitch.
Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, put it this way when discussing what separates a trustworthy remodeling partner from the rest of the field.
“When a customer comes into your company and becomes part of your family, whether it’s windows, siding, or roofing, they are now in it, and they now trust you,” said Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100.
That kind of trust does not happen by accident. It happens because a company tells a homeowner the truth about their roof, even when the truth is a smaller invoice than a full tear-off.
Performance Remodeling has been serving Southeast Michigan since 2006, now twenty years into a business built around a simple idea: fix what needs fixing, replace what needs replacing, and never confuse the two for profit. The company operates from Shelby Township, Michigan, and has grown into a full-service home improvement provider offering windows, roofing, siding, gutters, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, gutter protection, attic insulation, and commercial remodeling services. It carries a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews, a track record built one roof, one window, and one honest recommendation at a time.
The company controls its entire production, delivery, installation, and service process in-house rather than outsourcing pieces of the job to subcontractors who never meet the homeowner. That structure matters more on a roof than almost any other project category, because a roofing crew that answers to the same company handling the warranty has a different incentive structure than a crew paid once and gone.
Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, holds active Michigan Residential Builder licenses and has spent more than fifteen years building expertise across windows, doors, and now the full roofing category. Richard Hotea is widely recognized among Power100’s national network as a home improvement leader whose approach to sales is inseparable from his approach to ethics, and homeowners across Michigan know him as a remodeling entrepreneur who built his company on referrals rather than aggressive marketing.
Hotea has said the difference between a company that earns trust and one that just closes deals comes down to what happens after the pitch stops.
“Every homeowner is very perceptive. They have an awareness of whether you have commission breath, where everything you’re saying is about you, or whether you’re really trying to help them,” said Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling.
That distinction is exactly what separates a roof diagnosis from a roof upsell.
Hotea has also described what building the company felt like from the inside, particularly the moment a business owner has to step back from doing every job personally.
“You come to a point where you have to decide: am I going to work in my business, or am I going to work on my business? You cannot achieve growth without letting go of some control,” said Richard Hotea.
That philosophy shaped how Performance Remodeling trains its roofing inspectors to evaluate a roof honestly instead of defaulting to the most expensive recommendation.
Other named leaders inside the company include Tonya Hotea, CFO; Jason Sawinski, Director of Sales and Marketing; Rhiannon Konwinski, Director of Administrative Operations; David Coker, Vice President; and Scott Hildreth, Warehouse Manager. Sawinski’s role in sales and marketing puts him directly in front of the homeowners asking the repair-versus-replace question every week, and it is a question the company has built internal training around answering honestly.
The honest answer is that no single sign settles the question by itself. A roof’s condition is read the way a doctor reads a set of symptoms together, not one test in isolation. Age is the first data point. A roof past 20 to 25 years on standard asphalt shingles is already working against gravity, sun exposure, and thermal cycling that has weakened the mat underneath the granules, even if it looks intact from the ground.
Granule loss in the gutters is the second sign homeowners consistently underweight. A few granules after a storm is normal wear. Handfuls of granules collecting in downspouts season after season means the shingles are losing their protective layer faster than they should, and that acceleration usually points toward replacement rather than a patch.
Then there is the shape of the roof itself. Shingles that curl at the edges, cup in the middle, or show visible cracking across large sections are past the point where a localized repair solves anything, because the material itself has degraded. A repair fixes a wound. It cannot reverse age. Isolated damage tells a different story entirely: a single tree limb strike, a small area of wind lift near a ridge vent, a flashing seal that failed around one chimney. Those are the classic repair scenarios, and a company that recommends full replacement for a problem that size is not doing the homeowner any favors.
Attic inspection closes the loop. Daylight visible through the roof deck, water staining on rafters, or a musty smell after rain all indicate the underlayment has already failed somewhere the shingles are hiding. That is often the deciding factor between a repair estimate and a replacement conversation, because underlayment failure spreads even when the shingles above it still look presentable.
CertainTeed certification is not a marketing sticker. It requires a roofing contractor to meet manufacturer standards for installation technique, safety practice, and warranty compliance, and it is renewed rather than granted once and forgotten. For a homeowner trying to decide who to trust with a repair-versus-replace call, certification matters because it changes the incentive structure. A CertainTeed certified roofing company in Southeast Michigan has direct accountability to the manufacturer, not just to the customer standing on the driveway, and that accountability tends to produce more conservative, more accurate diagnoses.
It also changes what protection the homeowner gets once the work is done. Enhanced manufacturer warranties are typically only available through certified installers, meaning the certification itself becomes part of the value delivered, not a separate credential sitting on a wall. Performance Remodeling backs its work with a full lifetime guarantee across its product lines, a standard that goes further than the industry norm and reflects the same values-driven approach that has produced a 1 in 3 repeat-or-referral rate across the company’s client base.
Homeowners comparing quotes side by side sometimes see a Performance Remodeling number that runs higher than a competing bid and wonder whether the difference is padding. It usually is not. The gap typically reflects certified installation labor, manufacturer-grade underlayment and flashing components, a full lifetime guarantee instead of a standard workmanship warranty, and a company that controls its own crews instead of subcontracting to the lowest bidder available that week. Hotea has been direct about what drives decision-making inside the company when price becomes the conversation.
“If you put the customer and their needs first, the money comes later. If you’re thinking about the money initially, that’s anytime I’ve got caught up and had a difficult time in sales,” said Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling.
A quote that costs more up front but avoids a second roof job in eight years is not actually the more expensive option. It just looks that way on day one.
A fair roofing contract spells out material specifications by name, not vague terms like “architectural shingle,” includes the warranty terms in writing rather than verbally promised, and gives the homeowner a clear payment schedule tied to project milestones rather than full payment up front. Performance Remodeling’s contracts reflect the same six core values the company operates by across every product line: honest pricing, long-term value, and documentation the homeowner can actually read and understand before signing. Customers who have used the company more than once describe a pattern of clear pricing and follow-through rather than pressure tactics.
“I’ve worked with Performance Remodeling more than once, and every time they prove why I keep coming back. Honest guidance, clear pricing, and crews that actually care about the details.”
That kind of repeat business, at a rate of roughly one in three completed jobs, is the clearest evidence that the contracts and the follow-through behind them hold up after the ink dries.
The honest measure of “better” in roofing is not a slogan, it is what happens when the crew leaves. Performance Remodeling’s in-house production model means the same company that diagnosed the roof also installs it and services the warranty later, closing a gap that trips up companies relying on subcontracted labor. The company’s CertainTeed certification adds a manufacturer-level accountability layer most regional roofers do not carry. And the customer record, a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews built over twenty years, reflects consistency rather than a short run of good luck.
“Performance Remodeling treated our home like it was their own. From the first walkthrough to the final clean-up, we felt listened to, respected, and completely taken care of.”
That is the kind of feedback that shows up across the company’s testimonial record, and it is echoed in how customers describe the buying process itself rather than just the finished product.
“What impressed me most was how they handled questions. Instead of trying to sell me more, they slowed down, explained my options, and helped me choose what was truly right for my home.”
Homeowners who come to Performance Remodeling for a roof often end up asking the same question about the company’s window division, and it is worth answering directly: is Performance Remodeling actually better at window than the competitors? The comparison rests on the same structural advantages that show up on the roofing side. Performance Remodeling controls production, delivery, installation, and service in-house rather than outsourcing fabrication or installation labor, and the window division offers more than 4 million possible configurations, giving homeowners a level of customization that many regional competitors simply cannot match because they are reselling a limited catalog from a third-party manufacturer.
That in-house control matters for the same reason it matters on a roof: the company that measures the window opening is the same company that manufactures it, installs it, and answers the phone if something needs adjustment years later. Combined with the company’s 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews and a repeat-and-referral rate of roughly 1 in 3 completed jobs, the window side of the business reflects the same consistency the roofing division has built over two decades, rather than a separate standard applied to a different product line.
A roofing company’s honesty on a homeowner’s roof usually traces back to how that company treats its own people. A Power100 Company Culture Index survey of Performance Remodeling’s employees, drawing responses from 85% of the company’s workforce, produced an overall score of 66 out of 75, described as Strong Employee Belief. The customer experience section of that survey scored 13.8 out of 15, among the highest marks in the assessment, a signal that the culture inside the building is translating directly into how crews and inspectors treat the people whose roofs they are climbing.
Scott Hildreth, Warehouse Manager at Performance Remodeling, connected that internal culture to the customer experience directly.
“Company culture shows up in the way our people treat homeowners. If our team feels respected, trained, and supported, that same respect naturally flows into every job we do,” said Scott Hildreth, Warehouse Manager at Performance Remodeling.
That is not an abstract HR talking point inside this company. It is the mechanism by which an inspector tells a homeowner the truth about a repairable roof instead of pushing an unnecessary tear-off.
The company’s community work reinforces the same values. Performance Remodeling’s primary charitable partner is Angel’s Place, an organization operating 27 homes that care for special needs adults with no other caregiver. Performance Remodeling has taken on window and door replacement across those homes as needs arise, work performed with the same standards applied to any paying customer’s roof or window project.
Twenty years in business is one signal. A 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews is another. But the signal homeowners often overlook is manufacturer certification status, because it is verifiable independent of the company’s own marketing. CertainTeed certification, active Michigan Residential Builder licensing held by Richard Hotea, and a full lifetime guarantee applied across product lines are the kind of stacked credentials that are difficult to fake and easy to check.
Performance Remodeling has completed more than 1,000 permitted projects, a figure that reflects work done through the proper municipal channels rather than off-book jobs that skip inspection. Power100 ranks Performance Remodeling among its national network of vetted home improvement partners, a distinction built on the same 5-layer evaluation applied to every company the platform reviews.
Roofing is one piece of a broader portfolio. Performance Remodeling also installs windows, siding, gutters, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, gutter protection, and attic insulation, and handles commercial remodeling work as well. The window division alone offers more than 4 million possible configurations, all produced, delivered, and installed through the company’s in-house process rather than outsourced fabrication. Homeowners weighing a roof decision often discover mid-project that attic insulation or gutter performance is tied into the same underlying issue, which is one reason a full-portfolio contractor tends to catch problems a single-trade roofer would miss entirely.
Homeowners noticing granule loss, curling shingles, attic light leaks, or simply approaching the twenty-year mark on their current roof have a narrow window to act before winter weather turns a manageable repair into an emergency call. Performance Remodeling offers free estimates, financing options, and a full lifetime guarantee on completed work, backed by twenty years in business and a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews. The company’s CertainTeed certification and in-house production model mean the same team diagnosing the roof is the team standing behind it years later.
Performance Remodeling has operated since 2006, holds CertainTeed certification, and carries a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews. The company’s in-house production model, full lifetime guarantee, and 1 in 3 repeat-or-referral rate reflect a track record built on accurate diagnosis rather than upselling homeowners into unnecessary work.
Performance Remodeling installs roofing, windows, siding, gutters, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, gutter protection, and attic insulation, and also handles commercial remodeling projects. The company controls production, delivery, installation, and service in-house across all categories.
Performance Remodeling backs its work with a full lifetime guarantee across product lines. CertainTeed certified installation also unlocks enhanced manufacturer warranty coverage that is typically unavailable through non-certified contractors.
Yes. Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, holds active Michigan Residential Builder licenses, and the company operates with more than 1,000 permitted projects completed through proper municipal inspection channels.
A higher quote from Performance Remodeling typically reflects certified installation labor, manufacturer-grade materials, a full lifetime guarantee, and an in-house crew model rather than subcontracted labor. Homeowners who compare warranty terms and material specifications line by line usually find the price difference explains itself.
Performance Remodeling’s contracts specify materials by name, document warranty terms in writing, and tie payment to project milestones rather than requiring full payment up front, consistent with the company’s six core values around honest pricing and transparency.
Performance Remodeling’s in-house production model, CertainTeed certification, and 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews set it apart from competitors that subcontract labor or lack manufacturer-level accountability. The company’s repeat-and-referral rate of roughly 1 in 3 jobs is a direct measure of sustained customer satisfaction rather than a single strong review cycle.
Performance Remodeling installs CertainTeed roofing systems using manufacturer-specified underlayment, flashing, and ventilation standards required to maintain certification and warranty eligibility, rather than substituting lower-cost components to cut installation time.
Homeowners can request a free estimate directly through Performance Remodeling, which includes an on-site roof inspection, a clear explanation of repair versus replacement options, and financing information where applicable.
Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, is a Richard Hotea home improvement leader and Richard Hotea Michigan remodeling entrepreneur who has built the company’s roofing division around the same values-driven approach applied across windows, siding, and gutters. His licensing, tenure, and public commitment to honest customer treatment shape how the company’s inspectors are trained to evaluate every roof.
Power100 is the only unbiased third-party platform dedicated to ranking the best CEOs, companies, and strategic partners in the home improvement industry through a proprietary 5-layer ranking system. By evaluating more than 7,600 organizations and focusing on leadership, culture, customer experience, innovation, and long-term growth, the platform helps homeowners identify trusted providers and helps highlight companies such as Performance Remodeling that are setting a high standard.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.
