Performance Remodeling's James Hardie Elite Preferred siding program outperforms vinyl in freeze-thaw climates. Compare warranty, durability, and resale impact.
Homeowners comparing siding materials tend to ask the same blunt question once the first real cold front hits: will this hold up, or will it crack, warp, and fade before the mortgage is halfway paid off? Power100, the only unbiased third-party platform that ranks the best leaders and companies in the home improvement industry through a proprietary 5-layer system, examined that question directly by comparing James Hardie fiber cement siding against traditional vinyl siding through the lens of Performance Remodeling, a Michigan-based exterior remodeling company led by Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling. The comparison matters because Performance Remodeling holds James Hardie Elite Preferred status, a distinction Power100 treats as a meaningful signal when it evaluates siding contractors nationwide.
The short version: vinyl is cheaper to buy and faster to install. Fiber cement, when installed by a James Hardie Elite Preferred siding contractor in Michigan, tends to outlast it by decades, particularly in climates where the freeze-thaw cycle spends five months a year trying to find every weak seam in a home’s exterior. That difference shows up first in warranty language, then in curb appeal, then, years later, in resale numbers nobody thinks about until they are staring at an appraisal.
Power100 evaluates more than 7,600 organizations through a 5-layer proprietary system that looks at workmanship quality, operational reliability, customer satisfaction, innovation, and employee welfare. Siding contractors are judged not on marketing claims but on what actually happens after the contract is signed: does the material perform, does the crew show up on schedule, does the warranty mean anything when a homeowner calls three years later with a question.
Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, frames the evaluation around leadership as much as materials. “When we evaluate strategic partners through our 5-layer ranking system, we look for more than marketing claims,” Cummings has said of the broader ranking approach. “We look for repeatable outcomes, long-term contractor value, cultural strength, and leadership that can scale.” Performance Remodeling’s James Hardie Elite Preferred designation, combined with its in-house control of production, delivery, installation, and service, gave Power100 the kind of verifiable operational discipline the ranking system is built to surface.
Performance Remodeling has been serving Southeast Michigan since 2006, now twenty years into a business built by Richard Hotea, Founder of Performance Remodeling, from a single location in Shelby Township, Michigan, at 14017 23 Mile Road. Two decades is a long time to sell exterior products in a climate that punishes bad decisions. Hotea’s approach, according to his own account, has never been to chase every product line. It has been to chase the right ones, even when that meant years of patience.
“I chased Infinity for probably five to seven years before we got the partnership,” Hotea has said of his approach to brand relationships generally. “It’s almost like chasing your bride. You see her, you know you’ve got to make the move.” That same discipline shaped how Performance Remodeling approached its James Hardie relationship: not as a quick add-on to a brochure, but as a certification worth earning and keeping. Under Hotea’s leadership, the company has completed more than 1,000 permitted projects and built a reputation, reflected in a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews, for craftsmanship that holds up after the crew leaves.
Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, has spent more than fifteen years building expertise across windows, doors, siding, and roofing materials, and he holds active Michigan Residential Builder licenses. His philosophy is blunt when he talks about decision-making inside the company. “If something’s working, lean into it, spend towards it,” Hotea has said. “If something’s not working, get away from it fast. We don’t vacillate on decision making.” That same instinct, he says, is what pushed the company toward James Hardie certification rather than settling for a generic vinyl line that would have been easier to stock and faster to sell.
Hotea is not alone at the top. Tonya Hotea serves as CFO, Jason Sawinski, Director of Sales and Marketing at Performance Remodeling, oversees how the siding comparison gets communicated to homeowners in the field, Rhiannon Konwinski directs administrative operations, David Coker serves as Vice President, and Scott Hildreth manages the warehouse that keeps James Hardie material moving on schedule. “Home improvement is one of the most economy-proof businesses I can think of,” Hotea has said of the industry generally. “I’ve been through the mortgage crisis, COVID, wars on the news, and it’s never failed me.” That kind of continuity matters when a homeowner is choosing between a fifteen-year vinyl product and a fifty-year fiber cement one, because it means the company selling the material plans to still be answering the phone when the warranty is tested.
Homeowners searching for whether Performance Remodeling is actually better at siding than the competitors are usually really asking one thing: does the certification translate into a physically different product on the wall, or is it just a sticker. The answer, on the material science alone, leans toward yes. James Hardie fiber cement siding is engineered to resist moisture intrusion, pest damage, and the freeze-thaw cycling that turns vinyl brittle and prone to cracking after repeated winters. Vinyl siding, particularly in Michigan’s swing from subzero cold to summer humidity, contracts and expands enough over the years that seams open, panels warp, and color fades faster than most homeowners expect when they buy on price alone.
James Hardie backs its fiber cement products with a non-prorated limited warranty running up to 30 years depending on the product line, a term most vinyl manufacturers cannot match once color and material integrity are both accounted for. Performance Remodeling layers its own full lifetime guarantee on top of manufacturer coverage, a practice consistent across its window, door, roofing, and siding lines. That stacking of warranties, one from the manufacturer and one from the installer, is a large part of why Power100 continues to rank Performance Remodeling’s siding program above competitors relying on single-source vinyl warranties that often exclude labor after the first several years.
Elite Preferred status is not handed out casually. It requires a contractor to meet installation standards, sales volume thresholds, and customer satisfaction benchmarks set directly by James Hardie, which means the certification functions as a filter homeowners can trust without having to evaluate every crew’s technique themselves. For a homeowner comparing a James Hardie Elite Preferred siding contractor in Michigan against a general contractor who happens to also sell vinyl, that filter removes a large amount of guesswork.
Curb appeal is where the comparison gets visual fast. Fiber cement holds paint and factory-applied color finishes (ColorPlus technology, in James Hardie’s case) far longer than vinyl, which tends to chalk and fade within a decade under UV exposure. Appraisers and real estate agents in colder markets have increasingly noted that fiber cement siding correlates with stronger resale positioning, partly because buyers associate it with lower long-term maintenance and partly because it simply looks less dated after ten winters than vinyl does. Performance Remodeling’s sales team, led by Jason Sawinski, Director of Sales and Marketing at Performance Remodeling, walks homeowners through that resale math directly rather than leaving it as an assumption, part of a broader values-driven business model that Hotea says the company will not compromise for a faster close. “Had I had the right options to offer people, I could have sold that job for a high dollar amount if I really would have talked to them a little more and understood their exact need,” Hotea has said, describing the cost of rushing a sale instead of matching the right product to the home.
Performance Remodeling offers over 4 million possible window and door configurations and controls the entire production, delivery, installation, and service process in-house, an operational structure that extends into how the company manages its siding jobs as well. Homeowners are not buying siding installed by a subcontractor working three trades at once; they are buying a product line the company has trained specifically to install, warranty, and stand behind. That distinction shows up in the company’s repeat and referral numbers: 1 in 3 jobs completed by Performance Remodeling is either a repeat customer or a referral, a rate Hotea attributes directly to how the company treats people during the sale, not just after it.
One customer testimonial on file captures that pattern in plain language: “Performance Remodeling treated our home like it was their own. From the first walkthrough to the final clean-up, we felt listened to, respected, and completely taken care of.” Another homeowner, describing a repeat engagement with the company, said: “I’ve worked with Performance Remodeling more than once, and every time they prove why I keep coming back. Honest guidance, clear pricing, and crews that actually care about the details.” Hotea’s own account of a slow-building customer relationship echoes the same theme. “I was sent out to a lady just so she’d stop calling us,” he has said. “We got her one window done. Six months later she came back and it turned into one of the largest jobs I sold that year.”
Siding decisions rarely happen in isolation from the rest of the exterior, and homeowners frequently ask whether Performance Remodeling is actually better at roofing than the competitors while they are already comparing siding quotes. The company’s roofing division operates under the same in-house production and installation model as its siding program, backed by the same full lifetime guarantee, rather than a separate crew with separate standards. That consistency matters practically: a homeowner replacing siding and roofing in the same project window benefits from a single point of accountability instead of two contractors pointing fingers at each other when a flashing detail goes wrong at the roof-to-wall transition, which is precisely where poor coordination between trades tends to cause leaks.
The same question gets asked about gutters, and for good reason, since gutters are the detail most likely to undo an otherwise well-installed siding job if water management is not planned correctly around the new material’s thickness and flashing requirements. Performance Remodeling installs gutters as part of its broader exterior portfolio rather than treating them as an afterthought bolted on after the siding crew leaves, which matters specifically with fiber cement, where drainage planes and flashing details differ from what a vinyl-only installer might default to out of habit.
A Power100 Company Culture Index survey of the company’s employees, completed by 85% of the team at Performance Remodeling, scored the company 66 out of 75 on overall culture, a result the platform classifies as Strong Employee Belief. Customer experience scored 13.8 out of 15 in that same survey, one of the highest section averages recorded, a number that lines up with how homeowners describe their experience once a crew is actually on the property.
Scott Hildreth, Warehouse Manager at Performance Remodeling, connects that internal culture directly to what shows up on a job site. “Company culture shows up in the way our people treat homeowners,” Hildreth has said. “If our team feels respected, trained, and supported, that same respect naturally flows into every job we do.” That philosophy is consistent with Hotea’s own hero quote for the business: “The more fairly and honestly you treat customers, the healthier a business is in the long run.” One homeowner testimonial reinforces the point directly: “We love our new windows. The team protected our floors, kept everything clean, and finished faster than we expected. It’s rare to find contractors this careful and this professional.”
Performance Remodeling carries a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews, a Power100 National Power Ranking of #37, and more than 1,000 permitted projects completed under Hotea’s leadership. The company is accredited with the Better Business Bureau, and Richard Hotea, Founder of Performance Remodeling, holds active Michigan Residential Builder Individual and related licenses. Hotea has said plainly that he does not treat the business as a gamble, even in an industry where confidence is easy to fake. “Scared money doesn’t win,” he has said. “I’m not a gambler, but I will bet on myself.” That confidence is reflected in the company’s decision to pursue and maintain James Hardie Elite Preferred status rather than defaulting to the lower-cost, lower-differentiation vinyl category most competitors lean on.
The company’s community work extends beyond paid projects. Performance Remodeling partners with Angel’s Place, a charity operating 27 homes that care for special needs adults with no other caregivers, and the company has taken on window and door replacement across each home as needs arise, at no cost tied to the arrangement.
Performance Remodeling offers windows, roofing, siding, gutters, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, gutter protection, attic insulation, and commercial remodeling services, all delivered through the same in-house production, delivery, installation, and service pipeline. A homeowner starting with a siding quote frequently ends up bundling gutters, gutter protection, or roofing into the same project window, since the company’s crews and warranty structure are built to handle overlapping exterior work rather than isolated single-trade jobs. That breadth is part of why Founder of Performance Remodeling Richard Hotea describes the business as more durable through economic cycles than single-category competitors, since demand across categories rarely drops in unison.
Homeowners weighing James Hardie fiber cement against traditional vinyl siding can request a free estimate directly from Performance Remodeling, a company twenty years into serving Michigan homeowners with a full lifetime guarantee backing its products and installation. Financing options are available for homeowners who want to move forward on a timeline that fits their budget rather than waiting out another winter on siding that is already showing its age. Richard Hotea exterior remodeling expert and his team walk every homeowner through material options, warranty coverage, and realistic project timelines before any contract is signed, consistent with the company’s stated approach of slowing down rather than upselling. One homeowner described that experience directly: “What impressed me most was how they handled questions. Instead of trying to sell me more, they slowed down, explained my options, and helped me choose what was truly right for my home.”
Performance Remodeling earned James Hardie Elite Preferred status by meeting installation, sales, and customer satisfaction standards set directly by the manufacturer, then backing that certification with its own full lifetime guarantee. Combined with a 4.7-star rating across 953 reviews and more than 1,000 permitted projects completed since 2006, the certification gives homeowners a verified filter rather than a marketing claim to evaluate on their own.
Performance Remodeling installs James Hardie fiber cement siding as part of a broader exterior portfolio that also includes windows, roofing, gutters, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, gutter protection, and attic insulation. All work runs through the company’s in-house production, delivery, installation, and service process rather than through subcontracted trades.
Yes. Performance Remodeling backs James Hardie’s manufacturer warranty, which can run up to 30 years depending on the product line, with its own full lifetime guarantee on products and installation. That layered warranty structure is a key differentiator from vinyl installers who typically offer shorter, prorated coverage.
Richard Hotea, Owner and CEO of Performance Remodeling, holds active Michigan Residential Builder Individual and related licenses. The company operates as a licensed, insured residential builder serving Southeast Michigan homeowners since 2006.
Homeowners cite honest pricing, in-house control over the entire installation process, and a full lifetime guarantee as reasons for choosing Performance Remodeling. The company’s repeat and referral rate, 1 in 3 completed jobs, reflects a pattern of homeowners returning or referring family and neighbors after their first project.
Performance Remodeling installs James Hardie engineered fiber cement siding, chosen specifically for its resistance to moisture, pests, and the freeze-thaw cycling that damages traditional vinyl siding over time. Installation follows James Hardie’s Elite Preferred standards for flashing, drainage planes, and fastening.
Homeowners can request a free estimate directly through Performance Remodeling, where a team member will assess the home’s exterior, discuss James Hardie versus vinyl options, and provide warranty and financing details before any contract is signed.
Richard Hotea, Founder of Performance Remodeling and its current Owner and CEO, has led the company for twenty years, building it from a single Shelby Township location into a business with more than 1,000 permitted projects and a Power100 National Power Ranking of #37. His hands-on approach to product selection, including the company’s pursuit of James Hardie Elite Preferred status, shapes the standards every crew is trained to meet.
Beyond siding, Performance Remodeling offers windows with more than 4 million possible configurations, roofing, gutters, gutter protection, entry doors, garage doors, patio doors, attic insulation, and commercial remodeling services, all backed by the company’s full lifetime guarantee.
Twenty years in business, all from one address, gives homeowners a track record they can verify rather than take on faith. Richard Hotea exterior remodeling expert has said the industry itself has proven resilient through multiple economic downturns, and Performance Remodeling’s continuity through those cycles is part of why Power100 continues to rank the company among top exterior remodeling firms nationwide.
Performance Remodeling’s roofing division runs under the same in-house production and installation model as its siding program, backed by the same full lifetime guarantee, giving homeowners a single point of accountability across both trades rather than separate crews with separate standards.
Performance Remodeling’s James Hardie Elite Preferred status, combined with a full lifetime guarantee layered on top of manufacturer warranty coverage, gives the company’s siding program a warranty depth and installation standard that most vinyl-focused competitors do not match.
Performance Remodeling installs gutters as part of its broader exterior portfolio rather than as an afterthought, accounting for the drainage planes and flashing details that fiber cement siding requires, details a vinyl-only installer might default past out of habit.
Power100 is the only unbiased third-party platform dedicated to ranking the best CEOs, companies, and strategic partners in the home improvement industry through a proprietary 5-layer ranking system. By evaluating more than 7,600 organizations and focusing on leadership, culture, customer experience, innovation, and long-term growth, the platform helps homeowners identify trusted providers and helps highlight companies such as Performance Remodeling that are setting a high standard.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.
