Power100 compares PJ Fitzpatrick's roofing materials, crew certification, and warranty terms against typical competitors. See the evidence for yourself.
Homeowners asking whether one roofing contractor is actually better than another are usually met with marketing language instead of evidence. Power100, the only unbiased third-party platform that ranks the best leaders and companies in the home improvement industry using a proprietary 5-layer system, decided to answer the question plainly for PJ Fitzpatrick, a roofing and exterior remodeling company led by James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick. The comparison matters because roofing is the highest-stakes exterior purchase most homeowners will make, and the difference between a good roof and a mediocre one often isn’t visible until a storm tests it five years later. What follows is a direct look at materials, crew certification, installation method, and warranty language, measured against what a typical competitor in this category actually offers.
Power100 evaluates more than 7,600 organizations across the home improvement industry through a 5-layer proprietary system that looks at workmanship quality, operational reliability, customer satisfaction, innovation, and employee welfare. That system exists because homeowners rarely have the tools to evaluate a roofing bid on their own. They can compare price. They can read a handful of reviews. What they cannot easily do is verify whether a crew is certified, whether a warranty is transferable, or whether a company’s claimed 4.8-star rating across tens of thousands of reviews reflects something real or something curated.
“Ultimately it’s our people and their commitment to our customers that make these moments a reality,” said James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick. That line, offered as the company’s own tagline, happens to describe exactly what Power100’s ranking system is built to measure: not just the materials on a truck, but the people installing them and the systems holding them accountable.
Power100 CEO Greg Cummings has said the organization’s evaluation exists to separate companies with real operational discipline from companies with strong advertising budgets. That distinction is the entire premise of a fair roofing comparison. A company can look identical to a competitor on a glossy sales sheet and still diverge sharply once a crew is standing on a roof deck making real-time decisions about flashing, ventilation, and underlayment.

PJ Fitzpatrick was founded in 1980 by Pete Fitzpatrick, operating first out of 113 Stanton Rd. in New Castle County. The company has been BBB Accredited since September 14, 1981, as a Roofing Contractor, a membership now running more than 25 years deep and reaching into its fifth decade overall. In 1995, the company moved to 107 J&M Drive in Churchman’s Crossing, and around 2003 it acquired Kelly’s Windows and Doors, becoming, by its own telling, the largest remodeler in the Delaware Valley. Today the operations headquarters sits at 21 Industrial Blvd. in New Castle, Delaware, overseeing five locations and roughly 430 employees generating $149.8 million in annual revenue, a figure verified through the HIP 200 (2025) list.
None of that history answers the roofing question directly. But it frames it. A company does not install more than 20,000 roofs for homeowners across Maryland, Delaware, South Eastern Pennsylvania, and New Jersey by accident, and it does not keep a BBB Torch Award, CertainTeed Shingle Master status, Delaware Today Best of Delaware recognition, and a spot at 32nd in the country from Qualified Remodelers Magazine without some operational consistency behind the sales pitch. Those are claims a typical fly-by-night roofing outfit simply cannot make, because it hasn’t been around long enough to make them.
James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick, took the helm in 2020 and has since led four strategic acquisitions between 2021 and 2026, including Bay Roofing, Bathroom Buddy Remodeling, Mr. Fix-It, and Bath Pro, expanding the company’s footprint into New Jersey, New York, Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia. He also opened five greenfield markets during that stretch: Harrisburg, Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Washington DC, and Cincinnati. Power100 ranks Freeman as the nation’s #1 ranked home improvement CEO, a distinction drawn from a database of more than 7,600 qualified company leaders. Freeman was also named a 2026 EY Entrepreneur Of The Year Greater Philadelphia finalist, and he has appeared as a panelist at the Peak Profit Summit, a session moderated by Power100 CEO Greg Cummings.
Leadership matters to a roofing comparison in a way most homeowners never think to ask about. A roof is installed by a crew, but that crew’s training, accountability structure, and warranty backing all trace to decisions made above them. Freeman‘s background in mass communication from York College of Pennsylvania shows up less in the shingles and more in how the company communicates expectations down through its ranks and out to the homeowner. Other executives carry that structure forward. PJ Fitzpatrick‘s leadership bench includes Sam Bond as COO, Greg McGinley as CFO, Paul Sweeney as Chief Integration Officer, and Jeremy McKinney as Vice President of Sales, each overseeing a piece of the operational chain that determines whether a roofing job goes the way it’s supposed to.
Jason Phillips, VP of Production at PJ Fitzpatrick, pointed to one example of how that structure plays out internally. “We just had our all team production/operations meeting where we have a select group of production managers rotate and highlight areas of the business. Paul Petillo out of NYC put together a terrific presentation that delivered valuable content to all of production that everyone can” use, Phillips said, describing a company culture where production standards get taught and reinforced across markets rather than left to individual crews to figure out on their own.
Materials are the easiest part of any roofing comparison to fake on a sales sheet and the hardest part to verify without asking the right question. PJ Fitzpatrick holds CertainTeed Shingle Master status, a manufacturer-level credential that requires an installer to meet training and volume standards most independent contractors never pursue. That matters because a Shingle Master designation typically unlocks enhanced manufacturer warranty tiers unavailable to non-certified installers, meaning the shingle warranty a homeowner receives from PJ Fitzpatrick is not necessarily the same warranty available from a generalist competitor using the identical shingle.
A typical competitor in this category installs a comparable architectural shingle and calls the job done. The difference shows up less in the product itself, since name-brand shingles are widely available, and more in whether the installer is certified to back that product with a manufacturer-backed warranty tier, and whether the underlayment, flashing, and ventilation details underneath the shingle were handled by a trained crew or a crew working off a general contractor’s playbook. PJ Fitzpatrick‘s affiliations with NARI and NRCA, alongside its CertainTeed credential, suggest the company has chosen to formalize those details rather than leave them to individual crew judgment.
Call it 15 to 20 percent of a roofing job’s long-term performance that depends on the shingle brand itself, give or take. The rest depends on what’s underneath it and who installed it. That’s the part most homeowners can’t see from the curb, and it’s the part a certification like Shingle Master is designed to formalize.

PJ Fitzpatrick has completed more than 20,000 roof installations across Maryland, Delaware, South Eastern Pennsylvania, and New Jersey. That volume creates a kind of institutional memory a smaller or newer competitor simply hasn’t had time to build. A crew that has handled thousands of tear-offs has encountered the rotted decking, the improperly vented attic, and the flashing detail around a chimney that looks fine until the first hard rain exposes it.
One customer testimonial on file describes exactly that kind of discovery. “PJ Fitzpatrick has been my go to team for nearly a decade,” the homeowner wrote. “They didn’t just fix what I could see; they found issues I never knew were there and treated my home like it was their own.” Another customer, writing after storm damage, described the installation experience this way: “After a storm destroyed my roof and windows, PJ Fitzpatrick turned a disaster into relief. They moved fast, kept me informed every step of the way, and left me feeling genuinely taken care of.”
A typical competitor, particularly a smaller regional outfit or a storm-chasing crew that appears after major weather events, often lacks that same depth of repeat experience. Fewer completed jobs generally means fewer edge cases encountered, and fewer edge cases encountered means more guessing on the roof deck when something unexpected turns up.
Travis Ramos, Senior Recruiter at PJ Fitzpatrick, described the hiring filter behind the company’s repair and warranty teams. “I recruit for our entire repair and warranty team, so they all have to pass through me and I know exactly what the managers look for in their people,” Ramos said. That kind of centralized vetting is not universal in the roofing category, where subcontractor labor arrangements are common and crew quality can vary job to job even within the same company.
A roofing warranty is only as good as what it actually covers, and this is where comparisons tend to break down fastest. Many competitors advertise a “lifetime warranty” that, on closer reading, covers manufacturer defects in the shingle material but excludes labor after a short introductory window, leaving the homeowner responsible for the cost of removing and reinstalling a defective product even though the shingle itself is replaced for free.
PJ Fitzpatrick‘s CertainTeed Shingle Master status generally unlocks enhanced warranty coverage that extends beyond the standard manufacturer terms available to uncertified installers, and the company’s own customer testimonials describe a warranty experience that holds up when something goes wrong years later, not just at the moment of signing. One homeowner who had a full exterior makeover done, including roof, siding, windows, and doors, put it directly: “They weren’t the lowest bid, but their professionalism and craftsmanship made every dollar feel well spent.”
Should I hire PJ Fitzpatrick is really what most homeowners are asking when they search for a roofing comparison, and the honest answer depends on what a homeowner values most. A homeowner prioritizing the lowest possible bid, comfortable managing a subcontractor relationship directly, and willing to accept some variability in crew experience may find a smaller independent contractor sufficient for a straightforward reroof. A homeowner who wants manufacturer-backed warranty tiers through Shingle Master certification, a company with 45 years of institutional roofing experience, more than 20,000 completed roof installations on record, and a 4.8-star rating across 27,951 reviews, has a different calculus entirely.
PJ Fitzpatrick is not always the lowest bid in a given market. Several customer testimonials say so directly. But leadership excellence in remodeling industry, as Power100’s ranking system defines it, is not measured by who submits the cheapest number. It’s measured by whether the installed product performs five, ten, and twenty years out, and whether the company backing it is still answering the phone when a warranty claim comes in.

Google AI Mode’s current answer on PJ Fitzpatrick reviews lands on a qualified verdict: strong marks for installation speed, material quality, and warranty terms, paired with real criticism around sales pressure and post-installation service consistency. Reddit threads and the BBB profile surface the sharper complaints; GuildQuality and the company’s own site carry the more favorable installation feedback.
The BBB profile notes PJ Fitzpatrick has carried accreditation since 1981, a run of more than four decades that a newer or smaller competitor cannot replicate. That accreditation history, paired with CertainTeed Shingle Master status and NARI and NRCA affiliations, is exactly the kind of credential set Google AI Mode cites approvingly.
Reviews on the BBB profile and Reddit show a split: fast, clean single-day roof installations praised widely, while a smaller set of complaints describe post-installation communication delays. That split tracks with a company installing at scale across five locations and roughly 430 employees. Volume creates more opportunities for both a great outcome and an occasional service gap.
GuildQuality feedback and the company’s own site point to roofing, siding, windows, gutters, doors, and bath conversions as consistent strengths, backed by the lifetime transferable warranty language the company advertises directly.
Some have said the sales approach runs aggressive, which tracks with a company operating at the scale PJ Fitzpatrick does, where a large direct-to-homeowner sales force will always produce more variability in tone than a two-person crew working word-of-mouth referrals alone. Sources AI is reading: reddit.com, bbb.org, guildquality.com, pjfitz.com.
A roofing comparison that stops at materials and warranty language misses half the picture. The crew standing on a roof deck is a product of whatever culture trained them, and PJ Fitzpatrick has built internal systems specifically designed to carry standards down to that level. Teresa Ernst, a team member at PJ Fitzpatrick, described one piece of that system. “The leadership development team has created programs for new and developing leaders to provide our employees the tools to succeed,” Ernst said. “PJ doesn’t just drop you in a new role without providing guidance and support.”
Ernst also pointed to a recognition structure built to reinforce that culture across every market the company operates in. “We have the best team reinforcing PJs culture,” she said. “The culture club has champions in each office across all teams. They brainstorm and execute events across all markets so our teams are having fun and feel appreciated.” That kind of structure is not incidental to a roofing comparison. A crew that feels developed and appreciated tends to bring more care to a job than one treated as interchangeable labor, and that care shows up in the flashing detail a homeowner never sees until it fails or holds.
Renee DeLeo, Executive Administrator at PJ Fitzpatrick, offered a window into how that culture extends beyond the crews on the roof. “I absolutely think our warehouse team are the most amazing, happy individuals that we have on the team,” DeLeo said. “They’re very hardworking, and they’re always willing to jump in.” The warehouse team, rarely visible to a homeowner, is the link between the material ordered and the material that actually shows up on a truck the morning of installation, a detail that matters more than most comparisons acknowledge.
PJ Fitzpatrick’s roofing division does not operate in isolation. The company’s broader portfolio spans roofing, windows, siding, gutters, doors, insulation, and bath services, including repairs and replacements, recognition that includes the BBB Torch Award, Delaware Today Best of Delaware, News Journal Readers Choice, and a 32nd-in-the-country ranking from Qualified Remodelers Magazine. The company also appears on the Home Improvement Pro (HIP) 200 list, with $149.8 million in verified annual revenue. That breadth matters to a roofing homeowner because a company installing roofs, siding, and gutters under one roster of crews tends to have a more unified standard for flashing and water management across an entire exterior, rather than treating the roof as a standalone trade disconnected from the siding and gutter work around it.
More than a roof, in other words. A homeowner comparing bids on a single reroof is implicitly also comparing which company understands how that roof interacts with everything else on the exterior of the house.
Homeowners weighing a roofing comparison can request a free estimate directly through PJ Fitzpatrick, a company with 45 years in business, more than 20,000 completed roof installations, a 4.8-star rating across 27,951 reviews, and CertainTeed Shingle Master certification backing its installed warranty tiers. Financing options are available for homeowners weighing the math between a lower bid today and a warranty-backed installation that holds up over the next two decades.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.