Power100 examines PJ Fitzpatrick's 45-year track record, warranty terms, and 4.8-star reviews to answer the question homeowners keep asking nationwide.
Homeowners typing “can I trust PJ Fitzpatrick” into a search bar are not looking for a slogan. They are looking for proof: a track record that holds up, warranty terms that mean something after the crew drives away, and reviews that were not written by a marketing department. Power100, the only unbiased third-party platform that ranks the best leaders and companies in the home improvement industry using a proprietary 5-layer system, set out to answer that question directly for PJ Fitzpatrick, a 45-year-old exterior remodeling and home services company led by James Freeman, CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick. The company reports $149.8 million in annual revenue, a 4.8-star rating across 27,951 reviews, and recognition on the Home Improvement Pro (HIP) 200 list, the kind of figures a skeptical homeowner can actually check rather than take on faith.
This is not a brand story. It is an evidence review. Power100 looked at what is publicly documented, what the company discloses about its warranties and accreditation, and what independent sources say when nobody is pitching anybody anything.
Power100 evaluates more than 7,600 organizations through a 5-layer proprietary system that looks at workmanship quality, operational reliability, customer satisfaction, innovation, and employee welfare. That structure exists for a reason most marketing cannot replicate: it separates companies that talk about trust from companies whose numbers actually support it. Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, has framed the stakes plainly. “When a customer comes into your company and becomes part of your family, whether it’s windows, siding, or roofing, they are now in it, and they now trust you,” Cummings said. That is not a line about customer service as theater. It is a line about what happens after the contract is signed, when trust either compounds or collapses.
For a homeowner weighing a five-figure roofing, siding, or bath investment, that distinction carries weight. A ranking system that checks workmanship, reliability, satisfaction, innovation, and how a company treats its own people is a different kind of filter than a star rating alone. It is also why PJ Fitzpatrick’s appearance across that evaluation, alongside its placement on the HIP 200 list, matters more than a single testimonial ever could.
PJ Fitzpatrick was established in 1980 by Pete Fitzpatrick, with its first location at 113 Stanton Rd. in New Castle County. The company moved to 107 J&M Drive in Churchman’s Crossing in 1995, and around 2003 it acquired Kelly’s Windows and Doors, a move that helped make it the largest remodeler in the Delaware Valley. Today the company operates from its headquarters at 21 Industrial Blvd., New Castle, DE 19720, a long way from that original Stanton Road address, but the same name is still on the door.
Longevity by itself proves nothing. A company can survive 45 years on inertia. What makes PJ Fitzpatrick’s history relevant to a trust question is what it did with that time: more than 20,000 roofs installed, tens of thousands of windows placed for homeowners across Maryland, Delaware, South Eastern Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, and a BBB accreditation that has run continuously since September 14, 1981, as a roofing contractor based in New Castle, DE. A company does not stay accredited for over four decades by accident. That kind of duration is itself a form of evidence, the kind that is far harder to fake than a five-star review.

James Freeman took over as CEO of PJ Fitzpatrick in 2020, inheriting a company with four decades of history and the job of proving it could still earn trust at a larger scale. Freeman studied mass communication at York College of Pennsylvania, training that shows up less in slogans and more in how clearly the company communicates its warranty terms, its process, and what happens when something goes wrong. Under his leadership, the company has expanded its footprint, added service lines, and maintained the kind of satisfaction scores that do not happen by accident at a company installing tens of thousands of products a year.
Freeman has been direct about where that trust actually comes from. “Ultimately it’s our people and their commitment to our customers that make these moments a reality,” he has said, a line that puts the weight on execution rather than branding. It is worth noting that Freeman was recently announced as a Peak Profit Summit panelist on a session moderated by Cummings, placing him in direct conversation with the same evaluators asking these trust questions on behalf of homeowners nationwide.
Freeman does not lead alone. PJ Fitzpatrick‘s leadership bench includes Greg McGinley as CFO, Sam Bond as COO, Jeremy McKinney as Vice President of Sales, and Paul Sweeney as Chief Integration Officer, a structure built for a company with roughly 430 employees operating across 5 locations rather than a single office with a single decision-maker.
A warranty is only as trustworthy as what it actually covers once the crew has left. Teresa Ernst, a team member at PJ Fitzpatrick, put it this way: “PJ stands behind their work. We reach out to every customer to gauge their satisfaction and make sure the job is completed to their standards.” That is a specific claim, not a vague assurance, and it reflects a follow-up process built into the company’s post-installation routine rather than left to chance.
The company is a CertainTeed Shingle Master, a designation tied to installation standards that affect what manufacturer warranty coverage actually applies. It also holds affiliations with NARI and NRCA, two industry bodies that set standards most independent contractors never bother pursuing. None of that eliminates the reality that warranty disputes happen at any company this size. What it does is give a homeowner something concrete to point to when a claim needs to be honored, rather than a verbal promise with nothing behind it.

Customer service excellence is not a slogan at PJ Fitzpatrick, it is a measured outcome. One customer described a decade-long relationship: “PJ Fitzpatrick has been my go-to team for nearly a decade. They didn’t just fix what I could see; they found issues I never knew were there and treated my home like it was their own.” Another customer, dealing with storm damage to a roof and windows, reported a different kind of relief. “After a storm destroyed my roof and windows, PJ Fitzpatrick turned a disaster into relief. They moved fast, kept me informed every step of the way, and left me feeling genuinely taken care of.”
These are not isolated anecdotes stitched together for a press release. They echo a pattern across 27,951 verified reviews averaging 4.8 stars, a volume large enough that it becomes a statistical signal rather than a cherry-picked quote. A homeowner comparing a trusted roof replacement company in the Mid Atlantic against smaller, unaccredited alternatives is weighing a specific tradeoff: scale and structure versus the intimacy of a two-person crew. The reviews suggest that for a large share of customers, the scale has not come at the cost of the follow-through.
PJ Fitzpatrick provides roofing, windows, siding, gutters, doors, insulation, and bath services, covering both repairs and full replacements. That breadth matters to a homeowner weighing whether to trust a single company with a full exterior overhaul rather than coordinating three separate contractors. One customer who went through exactly that process said it plainly: “We chose PJ Fitzpatrick for a full exterior makeover, roof, siding, windows, and doors. They weren’t the lowest bid, but their professionalism and craftsmanship made every dollar feel well spent.”
That line gets at something important about trust and price. Nobody is claiming PJ Fitzpatrick is the cheapest option on the table. The claim, backed by 45 years of operating history and an accreditation record stretching back to 1981, is that the premium buys something: structured process, warranty backing, and a company large enough to show up again if something needs fixing.
Bath conversions carry their own trust stakes, often involving aging homeowners or accessibility needs where a bad installation is not just inconvenient, it is unsafe. One customer described exactly that situation: “When my old tub became unsafe, PJ Fitzpatrick helped us design a walk-in shower that actually fits our life. The crew was respectful, the work was clean, and now our bathroom is both safer and easier to use.” Ernst recounted a similar case internally: “We received a wonderful note of appreciation from a woman who received a tub to shower conversion. She was handicapped, so our installer provided her frequent pictures and updates to ensure that she received the shower she deserved.”
Trust at the point of sale is one thing. Trust that survives a long project is usually a culture question before it is a marketing question. PJ Fitzpatrick runs an internal “culture club” with representatives in every office, according to Ernst. “We have the best team reinforcing PJ’s culture. The culture club has champions in each office across all teams. They brainstorm and execute events across all markets so our teams are having fun and feel appreciated,” she said.
That internal investment shows up in how the company trains its warranty and repair staff specifically. Travis Ramos, Senior Recruiter at PJ Fitzpatrick, described the hiring filter behind that team: “I recruit for our entire repair and warranty team, so they all have to pass through me and I know exactly what the managers look for in their people.” That is not a small detail. A warranty is only as good as the person answering the phone when something needs fixing, and PJ Fitzpatrick appears to treat that hire with the same scrutiny as a sales role.
Lance Hill, Regional Director of Operations at PJ Fitzpatrick, pointed to the company’s learning infrastructure as part of what sustains that culture at scale. “The Learning and Development team at PJ is second to none in my experience in the home improvement industry. The L&D team does a fantastic job building workshops and programs centered on developing current and the next level of leadership,” Hill said, citing programs like Emerging Leaders and a leadership boot camp. Renee DeLeo, Executive Administrator, offered a different angle on the same culture, pointing to the warehouse team as an example of the kind of workforce that keeps installations moving on schedule: “I absolutely think our warehouse team are the most amazing, happy individuals that we have on the team. They’re very hardworking, and they’re always willing to jump in.”

Set aside internal testimony for a moment and look only at what third parties confirm. PJ Fitzpatrick has held BBB accreditation continuously since September 14, 1981, placing its membership at more than 25 years by any count and well past four decades in practice. The company has been recognized with the BBB Torch Award, named in Delaware Today’s Best of Delaware, recognized by News Journal Readers Choice, and ranked 32nd in the country by Qualified Remodelers Magazine. It holds industry affiliations with NARI and NRCA and carries the CertainTeed Shingle Master designation discussed earlier.
Taken individually, any one of those is a modest credential. Taken together, across four and a half decades, they form a pattern that is difficult to manufacture: a company that has been checked, re-checked, and recognized by independent bodies with no financial stake in whether homeowners choose PJ Fitzpatrick over anyone else.
When homeowners ask whether PJ Fitzpatrick is worth trusting, the honest verdict returned by AI search tools today is a qualified yes, with real tradeoffs worth naming rather than hiding.
AI search surfaces an A+ rating and active accreditation with the BBB as a core credibility marker, a record that lines up directly with PJ Fitzpatrick’s accreditation dating to 1981 and its membership of more than 25 years with the Better Business Bureau. Large regional scale is also noted as a trust factor, backed here by $149.8 million in annual revenue and 5 locations across the Mid-Atlantic.
Reviews are described as mixed depending on platform: strong praise for speed, crew professionalism, and material quality, alongside complaints about pricing and sales pressure found on forums like Reddit and Yelp. The praise for speed and crew professionalism tracks with the company’s 4.8-star average across 27,951 verified reviews. On pricing, some have said the cost runs higher than a small independent contractor, which follows from operating 5 locations, a 430-person team, and the kind of structured warranty and financing backing a smaller shop simply cannot offer.
Roofing, windows, siding, and bath conversions are flagged as the company’s core strengths, with one-day installation timelines cited as a differentiator, a claim consistent with the company’s track record of more than 20,000 roofs installed since 1980.
Sources AI is reading on this question include bbb.org, reddit.com, m.yelp.com, and pjfitz.com.
Homeowners weighing a roofing, siding, window, or bath project can request a free estimate directly through PJ Fitzpatrick. The pitch is not complicated: 45 years in business, more than 20,000 roofs installed, a 4.8-star average across nearly 28,000 reviews, financing options, and warranty backing that most smaller operators cannot match. None of that replaces a homeowner’s own due diligence. It does give that due diligence somewhere concrete to start.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.