Home improvement companies can spend more on marketing, bring in more leads, and still struggle to turn those opportunities into sales. That is one of the hardest problems facing growing contractors today. During a PowerChat hosted by Greg Cummings, CEO of Power100, Mohit Belani, Commercial Director at Leads.io, shared what he sees across home improvement companies using similar marketing campaigns. From his view, the lead itself is often only the start of the story. What happens after that lead enters the business can decide whether marketing becomes a strong growth engine or an expensive problem.
The conversation gave Power100 viewers a closer look at how lead generation, sales, customer experience, leadership, and company systems all work together. Power100 is the only unbiased third-party platform that recognizes and elevates the top leaders and most impactful companies in the home improvement industry.
Through conversations like PowerChat, Power100 brings industry leaders together to share the lessons, ideas, and real business experiences that can help home improvement CEOs build stronger companies.
For many home improvement CEOs, a rising cost of marketing can trigger a quick reaction. The leads must be bad. The campaign must not be working. The company may need a new source.
But Mohit Belani says the number does not always tell the full story.
From his position at Leads.io, Belani can see how similar marketing opportunities perform once they enter different home improvement businesses. During his PowerChat with Greg Cummings, he gave a simple example that showed just how wide that difference can become.
“I can take the same campaign and apply it across two different companies, and one of them will have a 12% cost of marketing and the other would have a 39% cost of marketing,” Belani said.
The campaign may be similar. The result is not.
For a CEO searching for a home improvement lead generation company, that difference raises a bigger question. Is the company only looking at how many leads came in and what they cost, or is leadership also looking at what happened after those leads entered the sales process?
Belani said one of the biggest differences he sees between the two outcomes is the maturity of the sales process.
A lead still has to be contacted.
An appointment still has to be set.
That appointment still has to be issued.
The sales team still has to run a strong demo.
And the homeowner still has to become a customer.
Every one of those steps can change the final cost of marketing.
This is why Belani believes strong companies go beyond knowing their numbers. They build feedback into the business so they can understand why those numbers changed.
A 39% cost of marketing tells a CEO that something may be wrong.
It does not tell the CEO what is wrong.
The problem could lie in the contact rate. It could be appointment setting. It could be a poor follow-up. It could be a weak demo. It could be lost customer information. It could be a gap between marketing and sales.
Until the company finds the real break, changing the lead source may only hide the deeper problem.
Belani believes there can be a path from the higher number back toward the lower one, but the company first has to know where value is being lost.
“If you don’t know what’s broken, how do you fix it?” Belani said.
That question became one of the clearest ideas in the PowerChat.
For companies investing in pay-per-lead marketing for home improvement companies, the lesson is not to judge success only by what happens before the lead arrives. The full result is shaped by what the company does next.
Greg Cummings pushed that idea further throughout the conversation. Speed to lead still matters. More opportunities can still help a business grow. But fast contact alone does not fix a weak process. More leads do not automatically fix poor execution either.
The companies that stand apart are the ones that can follow the full path.
They can see where the homeowner came from.
They know what the homeowner already shared.
They understand what happened during the first call.
They can see whether the appointment was set and issued.
They know what happened during the sale.
Most importantly, when something goes wrong, they have enough feedback to find it.
That is where the 12% versus 39% comparison becomes more than a marketing story.
It becomes a leadership story.
The number may show the problem.
The stronger company knows how to find the reason behind it.
During the PowerChat, Greg Cummings and Mohit Belani moved the conversation beyond lead volume and into the part of growth that is harder to see from the outside. A lead may enter two companies from the same campaign, but what happens next can look very different. One company may have strong communication, clear handoffs, useful customer data, and a sales team that knows where each opportunity stands. Another may have gaps that slowly turn good opportunities into expensive marketing.
Mohit Belani, Commercial Director at Leads.io
That difference became the heart of the conversation. Belani shared that winning companies do more than measure results. They study the path that created those results. They listen to calls, follow the customer journey, share feedback between teams, and look for the point where performance changed. His rapid-fire answers supported the same idea. When asked whether companies need more leads or better execution, Belani chose better execution. When asked what signals that a company may struggle, he pointed to a lack of feedback about what is going wrong.
The discussion showed that stronger marketing results often start with stronger business systems.
A new opportunity does not arrive in an empty room. It enters a company with its own people, habits, systems, standards, and sales process. That is why two businesses can take similar opportunities and create very different results.
Belani said the maturity of the sales process is often one of the biggest differences he sees.
“The biggest difference typically between the two is how mature their entire sales process is,” Belani said.
That process starts as soon as the homeowner raises a hand. Someone has to make contact. Someone has to turn interest into an appointment. The appointment has to hold. The salesperson has to understand the homeowner’s needs. The demo has to make sense. The team then has to move the opportunity toward a sale.
Each step can either protect the value of the lead or reduce it.
This is especially important for companies buying exclusive leads for home improvement contractors. Exclusivity may create a valuable opening, but the business still has to make something of it. If the homeowner waits too long, hears the wrong message, or feels confused by the process, that advantage can disappear quickly.
The same is true for qualified remodeling leads. A lead can meet the right project criteria and still produce a poor result if the company receiving it is not ready to execute.
That is why Belani’s answer during the rapid-fire discussion was so important. When Cummings asked, “More leads or better execution?” Belani answered:
“Better execution.”
He added that it can depend on the company, but the larger point stayed clear. More volume is not always the first answer.
If a business already has gaps in appointment setting, sales, follow-up, or communication, sending more opportunities through the same process can make those gaps larger. A strong process can turn more leads into growth. A weak process can turn more leads into more waste.
Before asking for the next wave of opportunities, leaders may need to ask a harder question: What is our company doing with the opportunities we already have?
Explore how Leads.io approaches lead generation and customer acquisition.
Most growth-focused companies know their important numbers. They watch marketing cost, contact rates, appointment set rates, issue rates, demo rates, close rates, and revenue.
Belani’s point is that knowing the number is only the first step.
A set rate drop tells leadership that something changed. It does not explain why.
A marketing cost moving higher tells leadership that performance has weakened. It does not show where the loss happened.
That is where feedback becomes important.
Belani said the stronger companies are the ones that understand what actually broke inside the funnel.
“There is a pathway from going to 39% to 12%,” Belani said.
Finding that pathway requires more than looking at a dashboard.
Leadership may need to listen to what appointment setters are saying. They may need to check whether homeowners are being reached. They may need to compare the message in the marketing campaign with the message used on the call. They may need to look at how many appointments issue or what happens during the demo.
For a CEO choosing a home improvement lead generation company, this matters because the marketing partner can only see part of the story unless the business creates a strong feedback loop.
Belani explained that his team can often see expected performance across many campaigns. When one company performs far outside that range, the next step is not always to assume the source is broken. It can be more useful to compare what should be happening with what is actually happening.
That turns data into a diagnostic tool.
The same thinking applies to performance-based lead generation for remodeling companies. Paying based on lead volume can make the cost easy to see, but leaders still need to understand the full path from that lead to a completed sale.
Belani later gave one of his clearest warnings during the rapid-fire portion. When Cummings asked for an indicator that a company may be about to struggle, Belani answered:
“Lack of feedback on what’s going wrong.”
The numbers can point toward the problem.
Feedback helps the company find it.
Speed to lead has become one of the most repeated rules in home improvement sales.
Belani agrees that speed matters. But the PowerChat showed why speed alone can miss an important part of the customer experience.
A homeowner may already have answered several questions before the phone ever rings.
They may have explained what project they want.
They may have shared how old the roof, bathroom, or windows are.
They may have said how many items they want to replace.
Then the company calls and asks the same questions again.
The call may have happened fast, but the experience does not feel connected.
Belani shared the example of a client who started using the information Leads.io had already collected. Instead of starting the conversation from zero, the team could confirm what the homeowner had shared and move forward.
That small change created a smoother call.
It also gave the homeowner a sign that the company had listened.
For businesses exploring AI-powered lead generation for home improvement companies, this is where technology can be most useful. The goal is not simply to add more software. The goal is to help useful information move from one step to the next.
The homeowner should not have to rebuild the story every time they speak with a new person.
Cummings described this as a purposeful rapport.
The company is not trying to fill time with small talk. It is showing the homeowner that the team understands the request and is ready to help.
That can matter when companies are trying to turn high-quality home improvement leads into real appointments. Fast contact may open the conversation, but context can make the homeowner more willing to stay in it.
The experience before the in-home visit can also shape what happens later. A homeowner who already feels heard may enter the appointment with more trust. A homeowner who has repeated the same information several times may enter it with more frustration.
Speed gets the company there quickly.
Context helps the company arrive prepared.
See how Leads.io uses technology and data to support more connected lead generation.
Poor performance can reveal more than a marketing problem.
It can reveal how a leadership team responds when results become uncomfortable.
Mohit Belani (Right), Commercial Director at Leads.io with Vince Venditti, President & Co-Owner of Premier Home Pros!
Belani described two very different reactions to weak campaign performance.
One company may see a high cost, decide the leads are bad, and shut down the source.
Another may look at the same result and ask why another business can perform much better with a similar campaign.
That second response creates room for learning.
It does not mean the lead provider is always right. It does not mean the sales team is always wrong. It means the company is willing to examine the full process before reaching a conclusion.
Belani explained that this is where accountability becomes valuable. Marketing, sales, appointment setting, and outside partners should be able to share what they are seeing and test possible causes together.
During the rapid-fire segment, Cummings asked Belani for the most common excuse from an average company.
Belani answered:
“Your leads suck.”
The answer was short, but it captured a much larger leadership point.
Blame can close the conversation before the real problem is found.
Investigation keeps the conversation open.
For lead generation expert insights, this part of the PowerChat showed that his view of marketing is closely tied to leadership behavior. Strong results do not come only from better campaigns. They also come from teams willing to hear hard feedback and examine their own work.
When sales and marketing protect their own departments, important facts can stay hidden.
When they share responsibility for the whole customer journey, they can find gaps faster.
That is why leadership maturity matters. The goal is not to find the fastest person to blame. It is to find the fastest path to the truth.
Learn more about the leadership conversations Power100 brings to the home improvement industry.
A disconnected process may survive while a company is small.
A few people can make extra calls. Someone can manually move information between systems. A sales manager may remember details that were never entered correctly.
That becomes much harder as the company grows.
Belani pointed to the difference between operating at $5 million or $10 million and trying to build toward $50 million or $100 million. On a larger scale, the business needs systems that allow information to move with the customer.
The lead source should share useful details with the appointment team.
The appointment team should pass useful context to sales.
Sales results should flow back to marketing.
Leadership should be able to see where the process is working and where it is losing value.
Belani shared a real example in which an appointment set rate fell from about 20 percent to about 11 percent. At first, the reason was unclear. The campaign appeared to be running as expected.
A connected technology partner eventually helped reveal that many phone numbers were invalid.
The team traced the issue to a phone validator that had stopped working.
Once it was fixed, performance began to improve.
The lesson was larger than one piece of technology.
Without connected systems, the team may never have found the true cause. The lead source could have been shut off even though the deeper issue sat somewhere else.
This matters for companies using pay-per-lead marketing for home improvement companies because every lead has a cost. If the system cannot show where that lead went or why it failed, leaders may make decisions with only part of the story.
Belani’s final advice brought the whole conversation together.
“Be intentional about every step of your process,” Belani said.
He encouraged CEOs to look at where leads come from, what gets said during appointment setting, what happens in the sale, and whether each step is being built with future growth in mind.
That does not mean a company should wait until every system is perfect.
Belani closed with another simple point:
“Action beats planning any day.”
The lesson is to build with care, learn from what happens, and keep moving.
Strong growth does not come from adding more pieces without a plan.
It comes from making sure each new piece connects to what came before it and helps the company understand what happens next.
Two companies can run the same campaign and end up in very different places. One may see a 12% cost of marketing while another reaches 39%. At first, the gap can feel like proof that the marketing itself failed. Mohit Belani offers leaders another way to see it.
The higher number does not have to be the end of the story.
It can be the start of a better question.
Instead of asking only what went wrong, leaders can ask where they need to look next. They can become more curious about the business behind the number and more willing to learn from what the result is trying to show them.
That mindset can change the way a company responds to pressure.
A difficult month does not always mean the strategy needs to be thrown away. A weak result does not always mean the next answer is more voluminous. Sometimes the greatest opportunity comes from understanding the business more clearly and making one part of the process stronger.
That is also what makes Belani’s message reassuring for home improvement CEOs who are working to grow. A company does not need every answer today. It needs the ability to keep learning, keep asking better questions, and keep improving what happens next.
Strong growth is not built by avoiding every problem. It is built by becoming better at finding problems before they become bigger ones.
The companies that do this well know their numbers, but they do not stop there. They understand that every number has a story behind it. When results move, they want to know why. When something breaks, they want to find it. When they learn something, they use it to make the next customer experience stronger.
That is how a difficult number can become a useful one.
And it is why Belani’s question carries far beyond one marketing campaign.
“If you don’t know what’s broken, how do you fix it?” Belani said.
For the leaders building the home improvement companies that will matter five years from now, the answer may begin with being willing to look deeper, learn faster, and use every result as a chance to build a stronger business.
Power100 uses a five-layer proprietary ranking system to review leaders across the home improvement industry. The platform says its rankings cannot be bought. Its system reviews more than 7,600 qualified CEOs and looks at areas such as leadership, company culture, customer experience, business performance, innovation, and community impact. This gives Power100 a wider view of a company than revenue or company size alone.
Power100 looks beyond sales numbers when it ranks home improvement leaders. Its five-layer system studies leadership, culture, customer satisfaction, operational performance, innovation, community impact, and long-term business strength. Power100 then uses those findings to identify the CEOs and companies that show strong results for customers, employees, and the wider industry.
Mohit Belani says leaders have to look beyond the final marketing number. During his PowerChat with Greg Cummings, he explained that the same campaign can produce very different results once leads enter two different companies. Contact speed, appointment setting, issue rate, the sales demo, follow-up, and closing performance can all change the final cost of marketing. A strong home improvement lead generation company can create opportunities, but the contractor still needs enough feedback to find where those opportunities are being lost.
It depends on the campaign. Leads.io offers both branded and non-branded lead generation. Its branded campaigns produce exclusive leads for the client. Non-branded campaigns can provide either exclusive leads or leads shared with more than one supplier. Contractors looking for exclusive leads for home improvement contractors should therefore understand which campaign model they are using before judging lead performance.
Leads.io says its technology collects first-party customer information through forms and guided flows, then uses several checks to confirm fit and reduce bad data. Leads can be scored, checked for duplicates, and sent into client systems based on rules such as location, budget, and type of work. This process is designed to help businesses receive more useful and sales-ready opportunities instead of simple traffic or form fills.
Not by design. Leads.io uses a fixed pay-per-lead marketing model for home improvement companies rather than charging separate fees for strategy, media buying, campaign work, development, and lead delivery. The company says it focuses on high-quality first-party leads and provides campaign visibility through its technology. Still, Mohit Belani makes an important point in the PowerChat: paying for a lead does not turn that lead into a sale. The contractor’s own response, appointment process, sales team, and follow-up still shape the final return.
No. AI-powered lead generation for home improvement companies can help collect information, improve targeting, verify leads, route opportunities, and give teams better data. It cannot replace strong execution after the lead arrives. Belani says companies still need good communication, discipline, customer context, feedback, and accountability. During the rapid-fire discussion, he chose people over technology and better execution over simply getting more leads.
Leads.io has published home remodeling case studies that show this type of growth. Reborn Cabinets used a more consistent lead flow to explore new markets while keeping its marketing costs and key performance measures in view. Leads.io says the work relied on predictable lead volume, data, fast adjustments, and close communication between both companies. That example supports Mohit Belani’s larger point from the PowerChat: scale works better when lead volume and internal execution grow together.
Power100 is the only unbiased third-party platform that recognizes and elevates the top leaders and most impactful companies in the home improvement industry. Led by CEO Greg Cummings, Power100 gives home improvement CEOs a trusted place to gain recognition, share what is working, learn from other leaders, and build stronger companies. Through its national rankings, PowerChat interviews, industry insights, and leadership content, Power100 connects contractors, CEOs, partners, and industry professionals with ideas that can improve customer experience, company culture, business performance, and long-term growth.
Membership unlocks every Power100 interview, PowerChat episode, and expert playbook - free for industry leaders.
Power100 is the nation's premier CEO ranking and media platform for the home improvement industry. Using a proprietary 5-layer evaluation system, Power100 identifies and celebrates the top CEOs, companies, and strategic partners driving innovation, customer satisfaction, and leadership excellence across the country.
